Here are the TMU Mustangs All-Americans.
NAIA All-Americans
| Year | Name | Team | Grade |
| 19-20 | Tim Soares | Second Team | Senior |
| 19-20 | Brock Gardner | Third Team | Senior |
| 18-19 | Hansel Atencia | Second Team | Senior |
| 18-19 | Delewis Johnson | Honorable Mention | Senior |
| 18-19 | Tim Soares | Honorable Mention | Junior |
| 17-18 | Lawrence Russell | First Team | Senior |
| 17-18 | Tim Soares | Third Team | Sophomore |
| 17-18 | Hansel Atencia | Honorable Mention | Junior |
| 16-17 | Reid Shackelford | Second Team | Senior |
| 16-17 | Lawrence Russell | Honorable Mention | Junior |
| 14-15 | Russell Byrd | Honorable Mention | Senior |
| 11-12 | Anthony Cammon | Honorable Mention | Senior |
| 08-09 | Ryan Zamroz | Honorable Mention | Senior |
| 07-08 | Ryan Zamroz | Second Team | Junior |
| 06-07 | Lucian Pesoli | Honorable Mention | Junior |
| 03-04 | Caleb Adcock | Honorable Mention | Sophomore |
| 99-00 | Joey Penberthy | First Team | Senior |
| 99-00 | Joclin Julmist | Third Team | Senior |
| 98-99 | Joey Penberthy | Third Team | Junior |
| 98-99 | Joclin Julmist | Honorable Mention | Junior |
| 97-98 | Joclin Julmist | Honorable Mention | Sophomore |
| 96-97 | Mike Penberthy | First Team | Senior |
| 95-96 | Mike Penberthy | First Team | Junior |
| 95-96 | Leo Gorauskas | Honorable Mention | Junior |
| 94-95 | James Mosley | Third Team | Junior |
