Here are the APU Cougars All-Americans.

NCAA All-Americans
Player Team Year(s)
Troy Leaf CCA – First Team 2015
NABC – First Team 2015
Basketball Times – Third Team 2015
Division II Bulletin – Fourth team 2015
Selom Mawugbe NABC – First Team 2020
CCA – Third Team 2020
NAIA All-Americans
Player Team Year(s)
Kendall Berkley Honorable Mention 1984
Chuck Boswell Honorable Mention 1969
John Bourne Second Team 2001-02
Demario Butler Third Team 2007
Honorable Mention 2006
Vance Carr Honorable Mention 1972
Kevin Daley First Team 2000
Honorable Mention 1999
Deric Daniels Honorable Mention 1995
Jeremy DeVries Honorable Mention 1998
Dennis Dickens Honorable Mention 1970
Ryan Dillon Honorable Mention 2004
Brandon Dunson Honorable Mention 2012
Larry English Honorable Mention 2005
Ed Forney Honorable Mention 1994
Caleb Gervin First Team 2003
Honorable Mention 2001
Dominique Johnson First Team 2010
Third Team 2009
Marshall Johnson Honorable Mention 2011
Jerome Joseph Third Team 2000
Honorable Mention 1999
Mitch Lebron Second Team 1982
Honorable Mention 1981
Steve McIlwain Honorable Mention 2002
Brett Michel Second Team 2004
Reggie Owens Second Team 2011
Dameon Page Honorable Mention 1997
Ric Reed Second Team 1974
Davon Roberts Second Team 2008
Lance Soderberg Second Team 2005-06
Jeff Staniland Honorable Mention 2003
Bob Terry Third Team 1993
Raymond Tutt Honorable Mention 1995
Dennis Vanzant Honorable Mention 1973-74
T.J. Walker First Team 1998-99
Jim Wilson Honorable Mention 1973
Eric Wattree Honorable Mention 1996
Ronnie Winbush Honorable Mention 1994
Scott Zea Honorable Mention 2007

NCCAA All-Americans (National Christian College)
Player Team Year(s)
Kendall Berkley First Team 1984
DeWayne Brewer First Team 1970
Bill DesRochers Second Team 1987
Dennis Dickens First Team 1969
Troy Leaf First Team 2014
Mitch Lebron First Team 1982
Second Team 1981
Ric Reed First Team 1974
Larry Shelton Second Team 1980
Dennis Vanzant First Team 1973-74
Jim Wilson First Team 1973