Here are TMU Mustangs baseball All-Americans.

• NAIA All-Americans (1st Team)
  • Tyler Diamond, The Master’s, 2008 season, Men’s Baseball, C
  • Steven Karkenny, The Master’s, 2013 season, Men’s Baseball, OF
  • Anthony Lepre, The Master’s, 2019 season, Men’s Baseball
  • Jerry Owens, The Master’s, 2003 season, Men’s Baseball, OF
  • Aaron Shackelford, The Master’s, 2019 season, Men’s Baseball

• NAIA All-Americans (2nd Team)
  • Jonah Jarrard, The Master’s, 2017 season, Men’s Baseball, C

• NAIA All-Americans (Hon. Mention)
  • Brad Hackworth, The Master’s, 2002 season, Men’s Baseball
  • Tyler Hergenrader, The Master’s, 2002 season, Men’s Baseball
  • Brett Jamie, The Master’s, 2003 season, Men’s Baseball, C
  • Steve Karkenny, The Master’s, 2014 season, Men’s Baseball
  • Tim Murphy, The Master’s, 2003 season, Men’s Baseball, 2B
  • Philip Seston, The Master’s, 2006 season, Men’s Baseball, OF
  • Chad Spencer, The Master’s, 2003 season, Men’s Baseball, P
  • Brandon Tisher, The Master’s, 2002 season, Men’s Baseball
  • A.J. Work, The Master’s, 2013 season, Men’s Baseball