Here are the NSU Sharks all-time home run leaders.
| Jake Anchia (2016-18) | 47 |
| Brandon Gomez (2016-17) | 35 |
| J.D. Martinez (2007-09) | 32 |
| Bryan Cook (2007-08) | 30 |
| Ed Mackie (1991-93) | 27 |
| Rich Palumbo (1991-92) | 26 |
| Justin Garcia (2015) | 26 |
| Claude Love (1993-97) | 25 |
| Matt Mindick (2005-08) | 25 |
| Areo Regoli (2011-12) | 25 |
