Here are the HPU Sharks NAIA All-Americans.

Llewellyn Smalley, 1997-98 (2nd)
J.J. Lucas, 1997-98 (3rd)
Shannon Lee, 1997-98 (HM)
Juergen Malbeck, 1996-97 (1st)
Llewellyn Smalley, 1996-97 (2nd)
Steve Richey, 1996-97 (HM)
Juergen Malbeck, 1995-96 (1st)
Steve Richey, 1995-96 (HM)
Tracey Evans, NAIA, 1994-95 (HM)
John Strickland, NAIA, 1994-95 (2nd)
John Strickland, NAIA, 1993-94 (2nd)
Tracey Evans, NAIA, 1993-94 (HM)
Brian Blackwell, NAIA, 1993-94 (HM)
Roger Huggins, NAIA, 1992-93 (1st)
David Smith, NAIA, 1992-93 (2nd)
James Williams, NAIA, 1992-93 (HM)
David Smith, NAIA, 1991-92 (2nd)
Hannes Haid, NAIA, 1990-91 (2nd)
James Williams, NAIA, 1990-91 (HM)
Hannes Haid, NAIA, 1989-90 (HM)
Fred Jones, NAIA, 1987-88 (3rd)
Fred Jones, NAIA, 1986-87, (HM)
Darryl Houston, NAIA, 1985-86, (1st)
James Rhodes, NAIA, 1985-86, (3rd)
Willie Preston, NAIA, 1985-86, (3rd)
Reno Cook, NAIA, 1984-85, (HM)