Here are the Shenandoah University Hornets all-time scoring leaders.
| Points | ||
| 1. 2297 | Phil DIXON (103 games) – 1992-96 | |
| 2. 2001 | Al WHITE (102 games) – 1992-96 | |
| 3. 1565 | Jeremiah LAWRENCE (103 games) – 2004-08 | |
| 4. 1463 | Mario PRITCHETT (84 games) – 1988-91 | |
| 5. 1346 | Billy BLAKE (99 games) – 1993-98 | |
| 6. 1343 | Avery GREEN (86 games) – 2010-14 | |
| 7. 1330 | Malcolm CLARK (78 games) – 2014-17 | |
| 8. 1319 | Ronald Merriwether (100 games) – 1998-02 | |
| 9. 1299 | Tyson Thompson (102 games) – 1998-00,01-03 | |
| 10. 1158 | Kevin KLINE (100 games) – 2007-11 | |