Here are four year players from College of the Canyons Cougars.
| Year | Name | School |
| 2023 | Quincy Arms Dillon Barrientos Andrew Henderson | William Penn University University of Alaska Anchorage Sonoma State University |
| 2020 | Robert Hunter Jah-Kez Moore Jordan Nash Zach Phipps | California State Polytechnic University, Pomona Dean College Nebraska Wesleyan University UC Merced |
| 2019 | Jude Agbasi Henry Flanagan Denzel Nwanguma Nissim Sevilla Anthony Simone | Whittier College Concordia University (IL) Grand Canyon University California Lutheran University Holy Names University |
| 2018 | Frankie Campbell Robert Moss Philip Webb | California State University, Stanislaus University of Saint Katherine University of Maine at Fort Kent |
| 2017 | Chris Collins Garrett Harding Alex Sanchez | St. Louis College of Pharmacy Brigham Young University (practice squad) Green Mounain College |
| 2016 | Jalen Ewell Harrison Haynes Tikko Moore Victor Nwaba Jacob Tobon | Wells College Howard University University of St. Francis Academy of Art University Pacific University |
| 2015 | Coley Apsay Ricardo Greaves Riley Honaker Brenden Otero Tullio Parry Brodric Smith | San Francisco State University University of Mobile Chico State University Bellevue University Tabor College Fisher College |
| 2014 | Zach Davis Roman Delgado David Horst Ilya Ilyayey Artur Mkrtychyan Dalibor Nonkovic | California Maritime Academy California Maritime Academy Texas A&M International University of St. Francis Concordia University, Oregon Western New Mexico University |
| 2013 | Tyler Barber Jaylen Bland Sam Colmenero Dylan Dyer John Green Brian Harris Ronald Harris Lionel Poole Jawhar Purdy Terrez Scott Temjae Singleton | California State University, Stanislaus University of California, Riverside San Francisco State University The Master’s College California Lutheran University California State University, Northridge Greenville College California Maritime Academy California State University, Stanislaus Western New Mexico University California State University, Fullerton |
| 2012 | Wesley Bartole Rafael Love | California State University, Stanislaus Eastern New Mexico University |
| 2011 | Parker Dominguez Ben Kimble Donald Smith | Holy Cross College University of Maine at Machias State University of New York, Purchase/California State University, Northridge |
| 2010 | CJ Atkins Brannon Bradley Eric Brown Rendon Dominguez Brian Kimble | University of Montana California Baptisit University Texas Southern University Waldorf College/California State University, Northridge University of Wisconsin-River Falls |
| 2009 | Behreng Behjoo Brooks Flanagan Travis Hayden Jason Holzwarth Justin Smith | California State University, Northridge Suffolk University California Lutheran University Concordia University, Oregon/Warner Pacific University of Hawaii at Hilo |
| 2008 | Kevin Bruce | University of Hawaii at Hilo |
| 2007 | Jovonne Augustus Shant Bicakci Jacob Briggs Everett Bryson Dwayne Jones Andre Murray | Grand Valley State University Waldorf College University of Hawaii at Hilo The Master’s College California State University, Los Angeles Portland State University |
| 2006 | Travis Gibb Scott Moore | Humboldt State University Kansas Wesleyan University |
| 2005 | Brett Bissett Cedric Davis Curtis Dunwoody Navid Khajavi Carlton Spencer Jordan Surratt | UCLA Waldorf College Rocky Mountain College California State University, Northridge San Jose State University Colorado State University/Colorado State University, Pueblo |
| 2004 | Pat Allen Andrew Bruckner Alex Dunwoody Kevin Valle | University of Dallas/University of Texas at Dallas University of California, Irvine/California Baptist University University of Great Falls/Waldorf College Dickinson State University |
| 2003 | Steven Brown John Chapman Carlos Escoto David Hungerford Matt Nelsen | University of Missouri at St. Louis University of Great Falls University of Great Falls San Francisco State University New Mexico Highlands University/Cal Poly Pomona |
| 2002 | Krishna Evans Dax Grooms Ricardo Suazo Murat Yildiz | Campbellsville University/California State University, Northridge Campbellsville University/California State University, Northridge University of Great Falls University of California, San Diego |
| 2001 | Nic Echevestre Jerome Edwards Nana Gbewonyo | University of California, Santa Cruz Marycrest College/Iowa Wesleyan College Washburn University |
| 2000 | Keith Cooley Eurskine Robinson Rahsard Walker | Erskine College/St. Augustine’s University Loyola Marymount University Northwestern Oklahoma State University |
| 1999 | Jason Ascencio Bryan Finley Charles Madison Mike Motherspaw Gabe Paez Woodely Polynice Ron Slater | Southern Illionois University Central Connecticut State University Portland State University University of California, Santa Barbara Whittier College/ California State University, Northridge California Lutheran University College of Notre Dame |
| 1998 | Tega Moceanu | University of Houston |
| 1997 | Kevin King Mike Posey Curtis Willis | Concordia University, Oregon Quincy University Quincy University |
| 1996 | Bill Bedgood Darrin Privett | California Lutheran University Humboltd State University |
| 1995 | Derek Ballard Malik Clark Rashe Dorsey | University of Utah University of Hawaii at Hilo University of La Verne |
| 1994 | Gene Barshtak Joe Bunning Bryan Camacho Randy Eason Jagos Medenica Erik Stephens | Concordia University, Oregon California State University, Northridge UCLA Concordia University, Oregon University of Maine at Machias Chico State University |
| 1993 | Rasaan Hall Cedric Jones Giancarlo Marcacini | Quincy University Eastern Oregon University/University of La Verne George Mason University |
| 1992 | Reggie Bell Jeff Dorst Tim Fontenette Jim Haigwood Pat Johnson David Langley | Quincy University California Lutheran University University of California, Santa Barbara California State University, Long Beach Pepperdine University Quincy University |
| 1991 | Chris Dyer Jason Harrison Anton Lisberg Dan Murphy Nick Sanderson | California State University, Hayward (East Bay) California State University, Hayward (East Bay) California State University, Dominguez Hills California State University, Hayward (East Bay) Brigham Young University |
| 1990 | Larry Allbriton Aaron Clark Tom Kelly Justin Scott | Hawaii Loa College Hawaii Loa College California State University, Northridge University of California, Davis |
| 1988 | Butch Mettinger | Idaho State University |
| 1987 | Anthony Hines Mitch McMullen Ron Stapp Eric Vincent | University of Tulsa San Diego State University California State University, Stanislaus California State University, San Bernardino |
| 1986 | Kevin Honaker James Mixon Vincent Ray | San Diego State University Southwest Missouri State University University of Hawaii at Hilo |
| 1985 | Pete Coeler David Strauss Karl Tompkins Deron White | The Master’s College University of Arizona Chapman University UCLA |
| 1983 | Mel Braxton Greg Trapp | California State University, Long Beach University of Oregon |
| 1982 | Dale Donohoe | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps |
| 1981 | Cory McMullen | Arizona State University |
| 1978 | George Sims Dan Starr | West Texas A&M University University of California, Santa Barbara |
| 1976 | Jesse Boyd | Portland State University |
| 1972 | Dan Smith | Brigham Young University |
