Here are the Allegheny College Gators all-time made threes leaders.
| 1.) | Perry Junius | 275 | 1983-87 | |
| 2.) | Jerry Ambooken | 205 | 1985-89 | |
| 3.) | Billy Urso | 187 | 2015-19 | |
| 4.) | Ryan Meerstein | 178 | 2001-06 | |
| 5.) | Ryan Stanko | 174 | 2010-14 | |
| 6.) | David Masciola | 169 | 1976-80 | |
| 7.) | Jordan Rawls | 154 | 2016-20 | |
| 7.) | Devone McLeod | 154 | 2009-13 | |
| 9.) | Bill Babe | 151 | 1978-82 | |
| 10.) | Craig Devinney | 144 | 2006-10 | |
| 11.) | Brian Roberts, Jr. | 139 | 2018-2022 | |
| 12.) | Josh Valentic | 129 | 2012-15 | |
| 12.) | Evan Zabriski | 129 | 2013-17 |
