Here are the Carroll College Fighting Saints all-conference players.
First Team All-Conference (1950-Present)
| Year | Name | Conference MVP |
| 2017-18 | Ryan Imhoff | MVP, NAIA Player of the Year |
| 2016-17 | Zach Taylor | MVP |
| Ryan Imhoff | ||
| 2015-16 | Zach Taylor | |
| Ryan Imhoff | ||
| 2011-12 | Ben Cutler | |
| 2011-12 | Andy Garland | |
| 2010-11 | Andy Garland | |
| 2009-10 | Andy Garland | MVP |
| Chris Medina | ||
| 2008-09 | Andy Garland | |
| Chad Vaculin | ||
| 2007-08 | Chad Vaculin | |
| 2006-07 | Eric Henkel | |
| Dallas Leslie | ||
| 2005-06 | Jeff Hays | |
| Sinan Guler | ||
| Travis Williams | ||
| 2004-05 | Andy Brown | MVP |
| Jeff Hays | ||
| Sinan Guler | ||
| 2003-04 | Chris Bond | |
| 2002-03 | Gary Lynch | |
| Jeff Mason | ||
| 2001-02 | Kirk Stiles | |
| Shane Gamradt | ||
| Gary Lynch | ||
| 2000-01 | J.D. Solomon | |
| Kirk Stiles | ||
| Gary Lynch | ||
| 1999-2000 | J.D. Solomon | |
| Kirk Stiles | ||
| 1998-99 | Kevin Van Nice | |
| 1997-98 | Kevin Van Nice | |
| 1996-97 | Guy Almquist | MVP |
| 1994-95 | Shawn Nelson | |
| Brandon Boedecker | ||
| 1993-94 | Drew Peterson | |
| 1992-93 | Drew Peterson | |
| 1991-92 | Bill Pilgeram | MVP |
| 1990-91 | Bill Pilgeram | MVP |
| Paul Slaymaker | ||
| 1989-90 | Bill Pilgeram | MVP |
| Glenn Bliss | ||
| 1988-89 | Glenn Bliss | MVP |
| Bill Pilgeram | ||
| 1986-87 | Tony Egland | MVP |
| Kenny Franklin | ||
| 1985-86 | Tony Egland | |
| 1983-84 | Bob Petrino | |
| 1981-82 | John Saunders | |
| 1979-80 | Mike Kelley | |
| 1978-79 | Mike Kelley | |
| 1976-77 | Rock Carlson | |
| 1974-75 | Dave Leslie | |
| 1973-74 | Dave Leslie | |
| Steve Shaw | ||
| 1968-69 | Pat Burns | |
| 1967-68 | Arnie Anderseon | |
| 1966-67 | Arnie Andersen | |
| Tony Sapit | ||
| 1965-66 | Arnie Andersen | |
| Tony Sapit | ||
| 1964-65 | Tony Albright | MVP |
| 1963-64 | Ron Darcy | MVP |
| 1962-63 | Ron Darcy | MVP |
| 1961-62 | Ron Darcy | MVP |
| 1956-57 | Jim Trudnowski | |
| 1955-56 | Dick House | |
| 1954-55 | Hal Hunter | |
| 1953-54 | Hal Hunter | |
| Walt Romasko | ||
| Larry Anderson | ||
| 1952-53 | Walt Romasko | |
| Claude Weaver | ||
| 1950-51 | Pat Kelly |