Here is the Colby College Mules 1,000 point club.
| No. | Name | Yrs. | G | FG | 3PT | FT | Points |
| 1. | Matt Hancock | 1987-90 | 104 | 744 | 198 | 792 | 2678 |
| 2. | Paul Harvey | 1975-78 | 92 | 851 | N/A | 373 | 2075 |
| 3. | Brad Moore | 1971-75 | 91 | 851 | N/A | 421 | 1935 |
| 4. | Harland Storey | 1981-85 | 92 | 679 | N/A | 352 | 1710 |
| 5. | John Daileanes | 1989-92 | 99 | 574 | 223 | 234 | 1605 |
| 6. | David Stephens | 1993-96 | 102 | 529 | 97 | 416 | 1571 |
| 7. | Doug Reinhardt | 1968-71 | 66 | 598 | N/A | 348 | 1542 |
| 8. | Adam Choice | 2007-10 | 101 | 548 | 53 | 385 | 1534 |
| 9. | Ken Stone | 1961-64 | 74 | 536 | N/A | 428 | 1500 |
| 10. | Matt Gaudet | 1992-95 | 101 | 479 | 188 | 341 | 1481 |
| 11. | Sam Jefferson | 2017-20 | 96 | 483 | 281 | 199 | 1439 |
| 12. | Chris Hudnut | 2012-16 | 86 | 516 | 46 | 325 | 1403 |
| 13. | Ken Allen | 1997-00 | 76 | 480 | 188 | 257 | 1366 |
| 14. | Kevin Whitmore | 1988-91 | 76 | 480 | 188 | 257 | 1357 |
| 15. | Matt Hanna | 2018-22 | 98 | 470 | 221 | 171 | 1332 |
| 16. | Mike Russell | 2008-11 | 99 | 531 | 1 | 238 | 1301 |
| 17. | Mike McGee | 1977-79 | 76 | 480 | N/A | 237 | 1251 |
| 18. | Ted Shiro | 1948-51 | 81 | 458 | N/A | 296 | 1212 |
| 19. | Drew Cohen | 2004-07 | 86 | 440 | 5 | 323 | 1208 |
| 20. | Patrick McGowan | 2002-05 | 91 | 432 | 155 | 153 | 1172 |
| 21. | Tom Dorion | 1987-91 | 105 | 411 | 79 | 266 | 1167 |
| 22. | Paul Belanger | 1976-80 | 92 | 525 | N/A | 104 | 1154 |
| 23. | Ernie Perry | 1983-87 | 95 | 525 | 84 | 161 | 1149 |
| 24. | Jay Dworkin | 1968-70 | 64 | 467 | N/A | 203 | 1137 |
| 25. | Steve Colella | 1970-74 | 91 | 463 | N/A | 209 | 1135 |
| 26 | Patrick Stewart | 2012-17 | 95 | 381 | 182 | 190 | 1134 |
| 27. | Sam Clark | 1997-01 | 90 | 419 | 21 | 264 | 1123 |
| 28. | John Rimas | 1989-92 | 104 | 492 | 18 | 118 | 1120 |
| 29. | Ryan Jann | 2012-16 | 96 | 365 | 152 | 227 | 1109 |
| 30. | Bob Patience | 1980-83 | 84 | 419 | N/A | 258 | 1096 |
| 31. | Nick Farrell | 2004-07 | 96 | 375 | 177 | 160 | 1087 |
| 32. | Bob Bruns | 1953-56 | 89 | 382 | N/A | 306 | 1070 |
| 33. | Ted Lallier | 1950-53 | 83 | 430 | N/A | 208 | 1068 |
| 34. | Pete Swartz | 1963-66 | 64 | 373 | N/A | 314 | 1060 |
| 35. | Charlie Twigg | 1954-57 | 75 | 385 | N/A | 267 | 1037 |
| 36. | Chris Powell | 1983-87 | 80 | 401 | 26 | 208 | 1035 |
| 37. | Mark Lake | 1976-80 | 90 | 420 | N/A | 178 | 1018 |
| 38. | Ken Federman | 1961-64 | 70 | 399 | N/A | 215 | 1013 |
| 39. | David Harvey | 1976-80 | 84 | 434 | N/A | 137 | 1005 |
| 40. | John Hebert | 1993-97 | 92 | 320 | 203 | 158 | 1001 |
