Here are Georgetown College Tigers NAIA All-Americans.
- 2021-22: Kyran Jones, Derrin Boyd – Honorable Mention
- 2020-21: Kyran Jones, Honorable Mention
- 2019-20: Chris Coffey, First Team; Eljay Cowherd, Third Team; Jacob Conway, Honorable Mention
- 2018-19: Eljay Cowherd, Third Team; Chris Coffey, Honorable Mention; Troy Steward, Honorable Mention
- 2017-18: Shadell Millinghaus, First Team; Quan Poindexter, Honorable Mention, Troy Steward, Honorable Mention
- 2016-17: Quan Poindexter, Honorable Mention; Troy Steward, Honorable Mention
- 2015-16: Deondrea McWhorter, First Team; Noah Cottrill, First Team, Tony Kimbro, Honorable Mention
- 2014-15: Deondre McWhorter, Second Team; Noah Cottrill, Third Team
- 2013-14: Monty Wilson, First Team
- 2012-13: Vic Moses, First Team
- 2011-12: Maurice Pearson, Third Team
- 2010-11: Vic Moses, Second Team; Eddie Gray, Honorable Mention
- 2009-10: Hollis Giles, Second Team; Vic Moses, Honorable Mention
- 2008-09: Demetrius Guions, Second Team; Vic Moses, Honorable Mention
- 2007-08: Gus Chase, First Team; Demetrius Guions, Honorable Mention
- 2006-07: Brian Silverhorn, First Team
- 2005-06: Brian Silverhorn, Second Team; Mark Surgalski, Honorable Mention
- 2004-05: Brian Silverhorn, Honorable Mention
- 2003-04: George Baker, First Team
- 2002-03: Quintin Bailey, Second Team
- 2001-02: Antwan Jones, Second Team
- 1999-00: Will Carlton, First Team
- 1998-99: Barry Bowman, First Team; Will Carlton, First Team
- 1997-98: Will Carlton, First Team
- 1995-96: Jermaine Brown, First Team
- 1994-95: Jason Woodard, First Team
- 1993-94: Mark Tandy, First Team; Jason Woodard, Second Team
- 1992-93: Russell Chadwell, Second Team; Mark Tandy, First Team
- 1991-92: Allen McCowan, First Team
- 1990-91: Russell Chadwell, Second Team
- 1974-75: Andy Williams, First Team
- 1973-74: Andy Williams, Second Team
- 1970-71: Kenny Davis, First Team
- 1969-70: Kenny Davis, First Team
- 1968-69: Kenny Davis, Second Team
- 1963-64: Cecil Tuttle, First Team; Dick Vories, Second Team
- 1962-63: Cecil Tuttle, First Team
- 1961-62: Joe Farris, Third Team; Dick Vories, Second Team
- 1958-59: Charles Grote, First Team; Raymond Withrow, Third Team
