Here are the Grace College Lancers NAIA All-Americans.
| NAIA All-AmericansYear | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Elijah Malone | Second Team | 2023 | |
| Frankie Davidson | Honorable Mention | 2022 | |
| Haden Deaton | Honorable Mention | 2020 | |
| Logan Godfrey | Honorable Mention | 2019 | |
| Brandon Vanderhegghen | Honorable Mention | 2016 | |
| Logan Irwin | Honorable Mention | 2015 | |
| Greg Miller | Honorable Mention | 2013 | |
| Bruce Grimm Jr. | First Team | 2013 | |
| Eric Gaff | First Team | 2009 | |
| Marcus Moore | Honorable Mention | 2008 | |
| Marcus Moore | Honorable Mention | 2007 | |
| Marcus Moore | Honorable Mention | 2006 | |
| Matt Abernethy | 2003 | ||
| Matt Abernethy | Second Team | 2002 | |
| Brian Elliott | Second Team | 1994 | |
| David James | 1993 | ||
| Scott Blum | 1993 | ||
| Scott Blum | 1992 | ||
| Doug Noll | Third Team | 1978 | |
| Tim Van Duyne | 1976 | ||
