Here are the Marian University Knights NAIA All-Americans.
| NAIA All-Americans | ||
| Christian Stewart | 2021-22 | Third Team |
| Cam Wolter | 2020-21 | Second Team |
| Cam Wolter | 2019-20 | Third Team |
| Wes Stowers | 2018-19 | Second Team |
| Reggie Kissoonlal | 2018-19 | Third Team |
| Wes Stowers | 2017-18 | Second Team |
| Aaron Evans | 2013-14 | Second Team |
| Aaron Evans | 2011-12 | Honorable Mention |
| Tim Adams | 2003-04 | First Team |
| James Gardner | 2001-02 | Second Team |
| Doug Pardue | 2000-01 | Second Team |
| Doug Pardue | 1998-99 | Third Team |
| Doug Pardue | 1997-98 | Honorable Mention |
| Jason Lucas | 1994-95 | First Team |
| Jason Lucas | 1992-93 | Honorable Mention |
| Rick Russell | 1989-90 | Third Team |