Here are the NSU Sharks single season scoring leaders.
| Points | |
| Will Yoakum (2022-23) | 727 |
| Sekou Sylla (2021-22) | 718 |
| David Riley (1994-95) | 711 |
| Mark Matthews (2018-19) | 680 |
| R.J. Sunahara (2022-23) | 642 |
| Jamie Lovett (1987-88) | 641 |
| Mark Matthews (2019-20) | 637 |
| Kelly Ackerman (1988-89) | 625 |
| David Riley (1993-94) | 619 |
| Juno Armstrong (1991-92) | 607 |
| Andy Platt (2000-01) | 592 |
| R.J. Sunahara (2021-22) | 580 |
| Sherard Hernandez (1998-99) | 570 |
| Sherard Hernandez (1997-98) | 565 |
| Dyron Curry (1999-00) | 563 |
| Chris Page (2015-16) | 531 |
