Here are the SJU Golden Eagles all-time steals leaders.
| Rank | Name | Steals | Years |
| 1. | Tom Roeder | 303 | 98-02 |
| 2. | Chris Jimenez | 220 | 08-12 |
| 3. | Jim Hickey | 196 | 82-85 |
| 4. | Fred Ostrick | 188 | 81-85 |
| 5. | Trey Black | 181 | 08-12 |
| 6. | David Acree | 178 | 05-09 |
| 7. | Andy Laurent | 151 | 13-17 |
| 8. | Dave Boucher | 140 | 89-93 |
| 9. | Mike West | 134 | 87-91 |
| 10. | Phil Lipari | 134 | 04-08 |
| 11. | Olivier Laurent | 110 | 09-12 |
