Here are TMU Mustangs all-time free throw percentage leaders.
| 878 Michael Penberthy 1993-97 |
| .859 Reid Shackelford 2013-17 |
| .853 Doug Leaman 1991-95 |
| .812 Joey Penberthy 1996-2000 |
| .810 Reggie McFerren 1998-2000 |
| .805 Hansel Atencia 2016-19 |
| .802 Phil Hahn 1985-89 |
| .802 Ryan Read 2003-06 |
| .801 Ryan Zamroz 2005-09 |
| .794 Carl Turner 1976-80 |