Here are the Westmont College Warriors All-Americans.
| NAIA All-Americans | |
| Santiago Aguirre | 2006-07 (3) |
| Justin Bessard | 2019-20 (HM) |
| Cory Blau | 2014-15 (HM), 2015-16 (2), 2016-17 (2) |
| Preston Branson | 2011-12 (2), 2012-13 (1) |
| Daniel Carlin | 2014-15 (2) |
| Abram Carrasco | 2019-20 (1) |
| Chris Clark | 2001-02 (2), 2002-03 (2) |
| Fred DeVaughn | 1972-73 (1) |
| Jim Dykstra | 1978-79 (2) |
| Chris Gonzales | 1999-00 (2) |
| Brian Gomes | 1997-98 (2), 1998-99 (1) |
| Jerry Karczewski | 2016-17 (HM), 2017-18 (HM) |
| C.J. Miller | 2013-14 (HM) |
| Olisa Nwachie | 2017-18 (3), 2018-19 (3) |
| Mitch Pierce | 2002-03 (3) |
| Dan Rasp | 2008-09 (HM), 2009-10 (HM) |
| Jordan Sachs | 2012-13 (HM) |
| Dave Schultz | 1982-83 (2), 1983-84 (1) |
| Mark Sheard | 1983-84 (2) |